9 AM to 5 PM CST

Our Opening Hours Mon. - Fri.

Edit Template

Menu

Edit Template

Menu

Where You Measure Concentration Matters

A patent claim can specify a concentration range and still be unclear.

The question in this case: measured where?

In University of Massachusetts v. L’Oréal, the patents covered skin treatments containing adenosine. UMass sued L’Oréal for infringement.

The claims referred to adenosine “applied to the dermal cells”—cells beneath the skin’s surface.

Did that mean the concentration in the product applied to the skin? Or the concentration that reaches the cells underneath?

UMass argued for the second reading. The lower court agreed, then ruled the asserted claims invalid for being unclear.

The Federal Circuit saw it differently.

It looked at the patent descriptions and what UMass had told the Patent Office. UMass had compared its ranges with earlier formulations using concentrations measured before application to the skin. Its explanations of the claim changes also supported that reading.

The range referred to the concentration in the product applied to the skin.

The appeals court set aside the invalidity ruling and sent the case back. It did not decide whether L’Oréal infringed.

Practical takeaway: cosmetic patent drafting should make clear what a concentration range describes and how it is measured. Do not leave readers guessing whether the number refers to the finished product or what reaches the tissue after application.

That means involving the formulation team while the application is being prepared. Explain the measurements behind the claimed ranges, and make sure the examples use those measurements consistently.

Keep the same care when responding to the Patent Office. Statements explaining an amendment or comparing the invention with earlier technology can affect how a court interprets the claims later.

A precise formula is not enough. You need precise words.

Source:
University of Massachusetts v. L’Oréal S.A.
Federal Circuit, June 13, 2022.

https://www.cafc.uscourts.gov/opinions-orders/21-1969.OPINION.6-13-2022_1964183.pdf

Recent News

  • All Posts
  • Blog
  • Copyrights
  • Patents
  • Trademarks

Contact Info

About Us

The law firm excels in patent drafting and prosecution, trademark analysis and prosecution, contract drafting and negotiating, and tech consultation for legal professional adapting to change.

Recent News

Copyright © 2025  Darryl Scott Law | All Rights Reserved.

Top