9 AM to 5 PM CST

Our Opening Hours Mon. - Fri.

Edit Template

Menu

Edit Template

Menu

A Negative PCT Opinion Is Not the Final Answer

Got a negative PCT written opinion? You may still get a patent.

When the opinion says your claims are not new or inventive enough, it can sound like the application has been refused.

But the written opinion is a preliminary assessment, not a final decision.

National and regional patent offices decide whether to grant a patent under their own laws. That happens during the national phase—the stage where you pursue patents through those individual offices.

You do not need a positive opinion to enter that stage. A negative opinion does not, by itself, keep you out. The filing requirements and deadlines still apply.

What the opinion gives you is an early look at the objections.

The next question is whether you can address them and still get protection that matters to the business.

Applicants can amend their claims before each national or regional office, subject to the applicable rules. Those amendments do not have to match. The claims pursued in the United States can differ from those pursued in Europe or Japan.

If the objections concern how broad the claims are, narrower claims may help. A specific formulation, dose, device configuration, or method step could address the objections while still covering the product the company plans to sell.

But those options depend on what was included in the original application.

In U.S. national-stage practice, amendments cannot introduce new matter. You cannot simply add missing technical details to support a claim you now want to pursue.

Practical takeaway: prepare for possible claim changes while the application is being drafted.

Describe meaningful variations, ranges, alternative configurations, and specific examples. Explain them clearly enough to support the narrower claims the company may need later.

Bring the scientists, engineers, and product team into that discussion. Consider which versions of the invention would still be commercially important if broader claims were unavailable.

Non-binding does not mean the objections can be ignored. They may carry forward into national examination.

Before deciding whether to proceed, review the objections with patent counsel, claim by claim. Consider what protection remains possible, whether it supports the business, and which filing deadlines are approaching.

A negative written opinion calls for a careful review—not an automatic decision to abandon the application.

Sources:

WIPO, PCT FAQs
https://www.wipo.int/en/web/pct-system/faqs/faqs

WIPO, PCT Applicant’s Guide, National Phase, paragraph 6.013
https://pctlegal.wipo.int/eGuide/view-doc.xhtml?doc-code=PCTNP&doc-lang=en&doc-type=guide

USPTO, MPEP 1893, National Stage
https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s1893.html

Recent News

  • All Posts
  • Blog
  • Copyrights
  • Patents
  • Trademarks

Contact Info

About Us

The law firm excels in patent drafting and prosecution, trademark analysis and prosecution, contract drafting and negotiating, and tech consultation for legal professional adapting to change.

Recent News

Copyright © 2025  Darryl Scott Law | All Rights Reserved.

Top