A recent Federal Circuit decision is a useful reminder that claim construction can make or break a patent case early.
In Socket Solutions v. Import Global, the patent holder obtained a preliminary injunction in the district court. On appeal, however, the Federal Circuit vacated the injunction and sent the case back for further proceedings.
The issue was not a final determination that the patent was invalid or not infringed. Instead, the Federal Circuit found problems with the district court’s construction of certain claim terms, including “backplate” and “pin.”
The court treated “pin” as a structural term that should receive its plain and ordinary meaning unless the patent clearly defines it differently or clearly disclaims that meaning. In other words, a structural claim term generally cannot be expanded into anything that performs the same function unless the patent record supports that broader reading.
The decision also reinforces that patent holders do not receive an automatic presumption of irreparable harm when seeking a preliminary injunction. Even when a patent holder presents strong infringement arguments, the traditional injunction factors still must be proven.
Practical takeaway: careful claim drafting matters. If a structural feature is important to the invention, the patent should describe it clearly and with enough support to protect the intended scope.
Federal Circuit opinion:
https://www.cafc.uscourts.gov/opinions-orders/25-1121.OPINION.8-4-2026_2733079.pdf







