A recent Federal Circuit decision is a useful reminder that flexible language in a patent claim still needs clear boundaries.
In Enviro Tech Chemical Services, Inc. v. Safe Foods Corp., the patent covered a method of treating poultry during processing with peracetic acid. Representative claim 1 required adjusting the peracetic acid-containing water to a pH of “about 7.6 to about 10.”
The case centered on the word “about.”
The Federal Circuit explained that approximation terms such as “about” and “approximately” are not automatically indefinite. However, the patent must still allow a person skilled in the field to understand the scope of the claimed range with reasonable certainty.
Here, the claim did not explain how far below 7.6 or above 10 the range could extend. The examples also gave conflicting guidance. Most experiments proceeded when the actual pH was within 0.3 of the target, while other experiments allowed larger deviations. One large-scale test involving 5.8 million chickens proceeded with deviations between 0.35 and 0.5.
The prosecution history did not resolve the uncertainty. The lower endpoint had been amended from “about 7.3” to “about 7.6” to distinguish prior art at pH 7.0, but there was no consistent explanation defining how much variation “about” permitted. The Federal Circuit affirmed that the term was indefinite, rendering the asserted claims invalid.
Practical takeaway: approximation language can be useful in food science and process technology, where pH, temperature, concentration, moisture, and processing time may vary. But the claims, specification, examples, and prosecution history should give consistent guidance about what that flexibility covers.
Federal Circuit opinion:
Enviro Tech Chemical Services, Inc. v. Safe Foods Corp.
Decided May 4, 2026.
https://www.cafc.uscourts.gov/opinions-orders/24-2160.OPINION.5-4-2026_2687268.pdf







